LAST WEEK ON THE DAILY SHOW, JON STEWART
was chatting with 20/20 's Cynthia McFadden about the
kidnapping of Elizabeth Smart, the Salt Lake City teen whose
family is almost parodically all-American. "Do you think they're
getting all this coverage because they're" -- he jokingly whispered
it -- "whiteys?" McFadden looked startled (they don't
joke this way over at ABC, at least not on the air), but she
quickly recovered: "They're also blondies."
A couple of days later, CNN interrupted its
regular news for live coverage of a press conference held by
Smart's media-addicted aunt and father. After they'd finished
rambling on about their desire to get Elizabeth back, and after
we'd again been shown the clips of Elizabeth performing in a
school production -- the networks just adore a photogenic victim
-- the anchorwoman in Atlanta asked why the local cops hadn't
joined the press conference. The on-scene reporter replied,
"A police spokesman says there's nothing new to report." Oh.
Of course, you can't really blame CNN for
milking the Smart case. Like a gangster's funeral or wildfire
roaring through Arizona, the snatching of a 14-year-old from
her bedroom is a classic populist story, one that's doubly seductive
in what seems to be the lull between al Qaeda attacks and the
War on Terror's move to Iraq. During rerun season, nothing plays
better than a nice crime yarn, be it Court TV's new Dominick
Dunne's Power, Privilege and Justice, whose ashen host appears
to have emerged from The Dead Zone , or the riveting
saga of Terry Barton, the 38-year-old U.S. Forest Service worker
accused of setting the disastrous Hayman, Colorado, fire because
(it is rumored) she can't shake off her bum husband. Her story
sounds incredibly juicy, and it's no wonder that CNN's clueless
but canny Connie Chung launched her new comedy news show by
interviewing Barton's brother-in-law (who, boringly, said she
didn't do it).
Even as Barton was being fitted for the J.
Lo role in Enough 2: The Conflagration , our most famous
ice maiden, Martha Stewart, was being pilloried for the suggestion
that she may have illegally engaged in "insider trading" of
shares in the biotech firm ImClone. Naturally, her discomfiture
has been greeted with no small glee -- The N.Y. Times
dubbed the reaction "blondenfreude" -- though to be fair, the
real villain is apparently ImClone's recently arrested CEO,
Sam Waksal. But he's just a faceless social climber (Time
ran a photo of the poor schmuck beaming alongside a sardonically
grinning Mick Jagger). In contrast, Stewart has already finished
her climb, transforming herself into a cultural archetype --
and lightning rod. While Erica Jong grumbles that Stewart's
domestic-goddess act keeps women in their homes, The Wall
Street Journal's Jennifer Grossman claims that feminists
dislike Stewart because she refuses to play the victim.
Stewart clearly pays a price for being the
classic Type A woman (think of American Beauty 's contempt
for Annette Bening's character), but her symbolic meaning far
transcends gender. Her career embodies social aspirations that
were every bit as typical of the '90s economic boom as dot-com
mania. Where creeps like Jack Welch merely wanted to own the
world, Stewart strove to remake it in line with the pseudo-aristocratic
fantasies of elegance and good taste you might expect of one
who'd escaped Polish working-class roots -- fantasies shared
by millions who yearn to know how to arrange flowers properly
or decorate a Fourth of July cake. Martha-ism is all about the
promise of worldly perfection -- she wants to make things nice
-- but once she became both an über-hausfrau and
a corporation, these promises took on a spooky new resonance.
Topping Ralph Lauren, the woman became her own product and
logo, an infomercial with legs. Frozen in her WASP-ish persona,
she began to seem madder and madder -- Ana Gasteyer's SNL
impression is of a sociopath whose chosen weapons are pie crusts
and Christmas ornaments -- and now that she has mortifying legal
woes, her carefully burnished brand is melting (her stock dropped
21 percent on Monday). Appearing on CBS's The Early Show
on Tuesday, she coldly refused to discuss her problems, prompting
CNN anchor Leon Harris to suggest that she'd be wiser to emulate
. . . Oprah. But this misses the whole point of being Martha
Stewart, which is to never, ever let it all hang out.